Skip to main content
Subscribe to our newsletter for 10% off full-price items for your order! T & C apply.
Man storing bicycle in storage shed

Outdoor Storage Shed vs. Renting a Storage Unit: The Pros and Cons

The need for extra storage has become a common challenge for many. Whether it's the seasonal gear that clutters your garage, the furniture waiting to find its place, or the overflow of cherished memories you can't quite let go of, the quest for additional storage space is a familiar journey.

But how do you decide the best way to tackle this quandary? Should you invest in an outdoor storage shed that nestles into your backyard, or is it wiser to opt for the convenience of renting a storage unit in a dedicated facility? Each choice comes with its own set of advantages and drawbacks, making this decision a pivotal one in your quest for storage solutions. Let’s dive in and compare.

Cost Comparison

When grappling with the decision of whether to invest in an outdoor storage shed or rent a storage unit, the cost is undoubtedly a pivotal factor to consider. Let's break down the cost comparison between these two options to help you make an informed choice.

Storage Shed

While outdoor storage sheds typically require a substantial upfront investment, they shine when it comes to long-term savings. Once you've purchased a shed, your expenses are primarily limited to occasional maintenance and potential upgrades. Over the years, this can translate into significant savings when compared to the monthly rental fees associated with storage units. 

Storage Unit

Renting a storage unit, on the other hand, involves ongoing monthly expenses that can accumulate over time. While this option provides flexibility and convenience, it's essential to calculate the total cost of renting a unit for the duration that you anticipate needing it. Consider the monthly rental fees, which can increase over time, as well as any additional costs like insurance. This calculation gives you a clear picture of the financial commitment required for the convenience of a storage unit.

Ultimately, the cost-effectiveness of your choice depends on your unique circumstances and storage needs. If you require short-term storage or the convenience of a secure facility, renting a storage unit might be the better choice. 

However, if you have long-term storage needs and are looking for a more budget-friendly option, investing in an outdoor storage shed could prove to be the wiser financial decision. Carefully assess your budget, the duration of storage required, and your preferences to determine which option aligns best with your individual needs.

Convenience and Accessibility

Fitness couple opening a shed full of exercise equipment

When it comes to storing your belongings, the ease of access can significantly impact your daily life. Let's explore how convenience and accessibility differ between an outdoor storage shed and a rented storage unit, and how this can influence your choice.

Storage Sheds

Outdoor storage sheds provide unparalleled convenience when it comes to accessing your possessions. With an outdoor storage shed, you have complete control over how you organize and retrieve your items. You can customize the space to your liking, making it a seamless extension of your home. Retrieving items is also as simple as taking a stroll outside. No need to drive to a remote location or adhere to a facility's operating hours. Your belongings are at your fingertips whenever you need them. 

Storage Units

On the flip side, rented storage units may require a bit more planning. While security measures are in place, you must visit during designated hours, potentially inconveniencing your schedule. The proximity of a storage shed ensures quick and hassle-free access. They also offer limited customization options. You're essentially leasing space in a shared facility, which may restrict how you arrange your belongings. However, the convenience of renting a unit lies in its versatility. If you move or require a different-sized unit, it's relatively easy to switch. 

Ultimately, the choice between a storage shed and a rented unit hinges on your lifestyle and how much you value the ease of access and flexibility in managing your stored items.

Ownership and Customization

Ownership and customization play a pivotal role in determining the perfect storage solution for your needs. Let's delve into the advantages of owning a storage shed and the constraints you might encounter when renting a storage unit.

Storage Shed

One of the most compelling aspects of owning a storage shed is the sense of ownership and control it grants you. When you invest in a storage shed, you're not just renting a space; you're acquiring an asset. This means you have the freedom to tailor the shed to your specific requirements. Want to add extra shelves or hooks, or even paint the interior to match your style? With a storage shed, you can do all this and more. It becomes an extension of your property, where you get to decide how it functions and looks. This level of ownership fosters a sense of autonomy that can be deeply satisfying for those who value their space and belongings.

Storage Unit

In contrast, rented storage units often come with restrictions on customization. These spaces are shared among multiple renters, and management typically enforces rules to maintain order and security. While you can certainly organize your items within your unit, making structural changes or customizing the space is usually not an option. This limitation can be frustrating if you have specific shelving or organizational needs. Additionally, you won't have the same level of personalization as you would with an owned storage shed. Renting a storage unit means adhering to the facility's guidelines and adapting to their pre-existing conditions. This can be a drawback for those who value complete control over their storage space.

Security and Maintenance

Up close of a storage shed lock

When it comes to safeguarding your things, security and maintenance are paramount considerations. Storage solutions, whether they are rented units or outdoor sheds, come with their own set of considerations in these aspects.

Storage Sheds

As the owner of a storage shed, you bear the responsibility for its upkeep. This includes periodic inspections for wear and tear, repainting or sealing to protect against the elements, and potential repairs. Proper maintenance ensures your shed remains durable and functional over the years. However, it's worth noting that these responsibilities also offer a level of control. You can proactively address issues and tailor maintenance to your shed's specific needs, enhancing its longevity. While the maintenance aspect may require some effort, it can be seen as an investment in preserving both your shed and the items it houses. 

Storage Units

Storage facilities are known for their commitment to security. They typically invest in robust security measures, such as surveillance cameras, controlled access systems, and on-site staff, to ensure your belongings stay safe. These layers of protection provide peace of mind, knowing your items are under constant watch. Furthermore, some facilities offer climate-controlled units to protect sensitive items from temperature fluctuations and humidity, bolstering their appeal for items like antiques, electronics, and documents. While security in storage units is generally high, it's essential to inquire about the specific measures employed by the facility you're considering to ensure they align with your expectations.

Space and Size Considerations

Storage Sheds

In the case of outdoor storage sheds, it's essential to analyze the dimensions and layout of your yard to determine the suitability of adding a shed. You want to ensure that the shed not only fits comfortably but also complements the aesthetics of your outdoor space. While outdoor sheds offer customization options, it's crucial to choose a size that accommodates your storage needs without overwhelming your property.

Storage Units

On the other hand, rented storage units come in a wide range of sizes, making it easier to find a space that aligns precisely with your requirements. Whether you have a few boxes or an entire household's worth of furniture and possessions, there's likely a storage unit size that suits your needs. This flexibility allows you to get a large or smaller unit, accommodating changes in your storage needs over time. However, it's vital to consider the monthly cost associated with larger units, as they can significantly impact your budget. Ultimately, whether you opt for an outdoor storage shed or a rented storage unit, assessing the available space and selecting the right size is key to optimizing your storage solution.

Accessibility and Location

Choosing the right location for your storage needs is a pivotal decision that can greatly impact your daily life. 

Storage sheds: 

It's important to consider factors like available yard space, zoning regulations, and proximity to your home. Placing the shed strategically can enhance its convenience, ensuring that accessing your stored items remains hassle-free. An easily accessible location can make it a breeze to retrieve seasonal gear, tools, or household items, saving you time and effort.

Storage Units

On the other hand, when examining the accessibility and convenience of storage unit locations, you'll appreciate the flexibility of having them scattered across various areas. When renting a storage unit, you can select a facility that is conveniently situated near your home or workplace, minimizing travel time and making frequent visits more manageable. Additionally, assessing the security and accessibility features of the chosen facility, such as operating hours and proximity to major routes, can further enhance the convenience of your storage solution. Whether you opt for an outdoor shed or a rented unit, the location you choose plays a significant role in ensuring that your stored belongings remain easily accessible and seamlessly integrated into your daily routine.

Keter outdoor storage shed

The choice between an outdoor storage shed and renting a storage unit boils down to a myriad of factors, each offering a unique set of advantages and drawbacks. One of the cons of having a shed in your yard is the maintenance. However, if you buy a Keter shed, they’re made of a sturdy resin. These sheds are weather-resistant and virtually maintenance-free. They also come in many sizes and are customizable. So, they’d make an excellent addition to any yard and are more flexible than traditional storage units and sheds.


We build in a sustainable manner.

We use innovative technologies and sustainable materials to build planet-friendly products that last a lifetime